Sunday, March 18, 2012

Classic tragedy from Shakespeare in Romeo and Juliet

How does Shakespeare incorporate classic tragedy?

After reading Act I: It is clear so far that this is a negative environment. It starts out with a public Capulet-Montague fight, Romeo is sad because Rosaline does not love him, and Juliet may be forced to marry County Paris. Although Juliet and Romeo fall in love, which is a happy thing, their love is destined to fail with such intolerant families.

            After reading Act II, Scene I: This was a short scene, but it is still clear Romeo is desperate for Juliet and there’s no turning back, and Mercutio and Benvolio question Romeo’s choice.

            After reading Act II, Scene II: This is a very classic scene. It is tragic because you can see how much Romeo and Juliet love each other, yet they must speak to each other in the night from different places so Romeo is not killed. There is also a desperate feeling from both of them that there is a possible chance they will be allowed to stay together.

            After reading Act II, Scene III: This scene’s tragic element is the fact that Friar Laurence is reluctant in letting Romeo and Juliet marry. Friar Laurence tries to sway Romeo, but Romeo’s tragic desire to love gets in the way.

            After reading Act II, Scene IV: This scene is sad because Benvolio and Mercutio are discussing how dangerous Tybalt is, and that Romeo stands no chance against him. After that, you can see that the nurse doesn’t fully approve of Romeo, which is also a bit sad.

            After reading Act II, Scene V: This scene is tragic because the nurse seems to be hurt or tired out or something along those lines, and she also tells Juliet that he’s not the best man she could have. It’s also a little bit sad in the beginning when Juliet is waiting impatiently for the nurse.

            After reading Act II, Scene VI: There wasn’t really anything tragic in this scene, but the fact that everything leading up to it have screwed up one way or another, you get an eerie feeling that something bad is going to happen sooner or later.

            After reading Act III, Scene I: Mercutio dies! He’s a great friend of Romeo, the main character! That angers and saddens Romeo. So then he kills Tybalt! Tybalt is Juliet’s cousin, and Juliet is saddened by this. Eventually the prince clears things up a bit.

            After reading Act III, Scene II: Juliet figures out Romeo is banished and Tybalt is dead from the nurse. Juliet is devastated and wants him to be found. Juliet is a main character becoming unhappy at the end of the scene.

            After reading Act III, Scene III: This scene is mainly tragic because you delve even deeper into Romeo’s woe. He feels that he’d almost rather die than be banished, or it is the exact same thing to him if he is leaving Juliet.

            After reading Act III, Scene IV: This scene is tragic because you know that Paris’s wedding to Juliet is coming up, which Juliet dreads happening because she loves Romeo, not Paris.

            After reading Act III, Scene V: This scene is tragic because Romeo is getting his last glimpse of Juliet before he must leave Verona to Mantua, and they are both very saddened by this. Neither of them wants Romeo to leave, but they know it is inevitable. Also, Juliet’s parents figure out who Juliet truly loves and they are furious. This raises the chances of Juliet marrying Paris.

            After reading Act IV, Scene I: This is tragic because there is culmination of a desperate plan that, as we find out later, is doomed to fail. Also, Juliet is very heartbroken right now at Romeo’s banishment.

            After reading Act IV, Scene II: This scene is only tragic because you can see how close Juliet is to marrying County Paris, and also the fact she’s about to commit her plan by faking her death to escape to Romeo.

            After reading Act IV, Scene III: This scene evokes tragedy by Juliet giving a long monologue about her heartbreak and then taking the poison that turns her asleep.

            After reading Act IV, Scene IV: This scene is just barely tragic because you know the nurse is about to find Juliet, very likely thinking she is dead, given that only Friar Laurence knows about the plan.

            After reading Act IV, Scene V: This scene is tragic because everyone thinks Juliet is dead and is mourning her “death” very heavily. Even Paris doesn’t know what to do and quite how to react, just to keep talking about how terrible it is that Juliet is dead and that it is a “woful, woful day.” If I understood the musician conversation more I would probably figure out that that conversation evoked tragedy as well.

            After reading Act V, Scene I: This is the point where you know it’s going to fall apart. Benvolio tells Romeo that Juliet’s dead, and Romeo buys poison. Romeo is going to kill himself, and there’s nothing that can stop him. Only one scene in the whole play can top the tragedy of that.

            After reading Act V, Scene II: All this short scene does is explain why the plan tragically failed – Friar John, for a reason I couldn’t exactly understand from the text, couldn’t send the important letter to Romeo, and now Romeo is about to kill himself. Friar Laurence is also saddened by this.

            After finishing: People died – many people. The unnecessary death of County Paris came first, after Romeo inevitably had to fight in order to die next to Juliet. Although this was sad, I was angrier that Romeo didn’t just surrender the fight and die like he wanted to, but the story was written 400 years ago, so I’ll have to deal with it. After that, Romeo died after taking poison right next to Juliet in her tomb. Juliet wakes, and despite Friar Laurence’s instructions, she kills herself with Romeo’s dagger. Then news spreads about their deaths, and both Montagues and Capulet come to the tomb. Lord Montague gives news about Lady Montague’s unnecessary death. We also figure out the tragic truth that it takes both their children to die for each other in order to make up for past quarrels.

4 comments:

  1. Wow...now that you break it down scene by scene I realize how tragic this play really is...

    ReplyDelete
  2. Wow! This is a great analysis of Romeo and Juliet. I love how you broke it down scene by scene in every act!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Wow


    I love how you wrote about things from each scene. Very detailed, nice job!

    ReplyDelete